Mariah Carey Awarded $92K After Judge Dismisses Copyright Lawsuit Over ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS IS YOU

Walter Sena
By
Mariah Carey Awarded $92K After Judge Dismisses Copyright Lawsuit Over ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS IS YOU
Mariah Carey
Mariah Carey has scored a legal victory after a U.S. federal judge dismissed a long-running copyright infringement lawsuit targeting her iconic holiday hit, ALL I WANT FOR  CHRISTMAS IS YOU. Following the dismissal, the court ordered that Mariah Carey be awarded more than $92,000 in legal fees, effectively closing the case and reinforcing the song’s protected status as a Christmas classic.

The lawsuit was filed by songwriter Andy Stone, who claimed Mariah Carey’s 1994 chart-topping record copied elements from an earlier song of the same title. Stone sought $20 million in damages, alleging similarities in lyrics and overall composition. However, the court found those claims to be without merit.

In a firm ruling, the judge stated that the alleged similarities were generic and commonplace within holiday music, noting that shared phrases and themes such as longing for love during Christmas are not subject to exclusive ownership. The court concluded that Mariah Carey’s song was original and distinct and that the lawsuit failed to meet the legal threshold required for copyright infringement.

More significantly, the judge imposed sanctions against the plaintiffs’ legal team, describing the arguments presented as frivolous. This led to the order that Stone cover a substantial portion of Mariah Carey’s legal costs, amounting to over $92,000.

The decision officially brings the case to an end and further cements ALL I WANT FOR  CHRISTMAS IS YOU as one of the most successful and enduring holiday songs in music history. Released nearly three decades ago, the track continues to dominate global charts every festive season, generating millions in revenue and cultural relevance.

For Mariah Carey, the ruling is not just a legal win but a clear affirmation of her creative legacy. 


Source: Scripps News

Comments

MORE FROM
entertainment

More From 3Music News

Akwaboah Celebrates Different SHADES OF LOVE
music | entertainment | fashion & lifestyle | culture | BY Christabel Newman | February 23rd, 2026

Akwaboah Celebrates Different SHADES OF LOVE

Love and live music filled the air in Accra yesterday as celebrated highlife singer and songwriter, Akwaboah hosted the 2026 edition of his annual SHADES OF LOVE concert...

Adina Thembi Announces Second Studio Album BECOMING
music | entertainment | fashion & lifestyle | BY Christabel Newman | February 23rd, 2026

Adina Thembi Announces Second Studio Album BECOMING

Ghanaian-South African vocalist, Adina, has officially revealed that her second studio album, BECOMING, is set for release in 2026 sparking excitement among her ever-growing fanbase...

Vybz Kartel And Mavado Set To Reignite Iconic Rivalry In Malta
music | entertainment | culture | BY Christabel Newman | February 23rd, 2026

Vybz Kartel And Mavado Set To Reignite Iconic Rivalry In Malta

The two dancehall heavyweights will headline a three-day festival in Malta from September 10–13, 2026 in what is being billed as a historic reunion of the legendary Gaza vs. Gully rivalry…

Philkeyz Defends Human Creativity, Says A.I Can’t Replace Real Musicians
music | entertainment | BY Christabel Newman | February 23rd, 2026

Philkeyz Defends Human Creativity, Says A.I Can’t Replace Real Musicians

Philkeyz spoke passionately about the power of intentional artistry and long-term vision in music. Reflecting on his collaborations with Kizz Daniel, Philkeyz described the process as seamless…

“There Are Lots Of BeatMakers But Fewer Producers”- Philkeyz
music | entertainment | BY Christabel Newman | February 23rd, 2026

“There Are Lots Of BeatMakers But Fewer Producers”- Philkeyz

“Sometimes the difference between one artiste and another is simply finance and the right people around them.”

AlorG Celebrates Brotherhood In New Visuals
music | entertainment | culture | BY Christabel Newman | February 20th, 2026

AlorG Celebrates Brotherhood In New Visuals

Ghanaian artiste, AlorG, has unveiled the official music video for his latest single, MY BROTHERS, following the track’s earlier release this year...

Cardi B Surprises Los Angeles Crowd With Tyla Appearance
music | entertainment | fashion & lifestyle | culture | BY Christabel Newman | February 20th, 2026

Cardi B Surprises Los Angeles Crowd With Tyla Appearance

American rap superstar, Cardi B, delivered a major surprise during her sold-out LITTLE MISS DRAMA TOUR stop at the Kia Forum in Los Angeles, bringing out South African hitmaker Tyla as a special guest...

Popcaan Enstooled As Chief In Asebu Traditional Area
music | entertainment | culture | BY Christabel Newman | February 20th, 2026

Popcaan Enstooled As Chief In Asebu Traditional Area

Jamaican dancehall heavyweight, Popcaan, has been enstooled as a traditional chief in Ghana, strengthening the cultural bridge between the Caribbean and the African continent...

Kojo Antwi Shares The Story Behind MR. MUSIC MAN
music | entertainment | culture | BY Christabel Newman | February 20th, 2026

Kojo Antwi Shares The Story Behind MR. MUSIC MAN

Ghanaian music legend Kojo Antwi, widely known as Mr Music Man, has officially unveiled his long-awaited memoir, MR. MUSIC MAN: THE JOURNEY…

Mayweather & Tyson To Clash In Congo Exhibition Showdown
entertainment | sports | BY Christabel Newman | February 20th, 2026

Mayweather & Tyson To Clash In Congo Exhibition Showdown

Boxing legends, Mike Tyson and Floyd Mayweather Jr. are reportedly set to square off in a blockbuster exhibition bout on April 25, 2026, in the Democratic Republic of the Congo.

Tearful Sherri Shepherd Rises to Tyra Banks’ Defense After Netflix AMERICA'S NEXT TOP MODEL Documentary Sparks Backlash
entertainment | fashion & lifestyle | culture | BY Walter Sena | February 20th, 2026

Tearful Sherri Shepherd Rises to Tyra Banks’ Defense After Netflix AMERICA'S NEXT TOP MODEL Documentary Sparks Backlash

In a heartfelt moment on her daytime talk show, Sherri, Emmy‑winning host Sherri Shepherd offered an emotional defense of supermodel and creator Tyra Banks amid the intense backlash triggered by Netflix’s controversial documentary Reality Check: INSIDE AMERICA'S NEXT TOP MODEL. 

The Jennifer Hudson Show Renews for Fifth Season Amid Daytime TV Shake‑Up
entertainment | fashion & lifestyle | culture | BY Walter Sena | February 20th, 2026

The Jennifer Hudson Show Renews for Fifth Season Amid Daytime TV Shake‑Up

In a major vote of confidence for the daytime talk show landscape, Fox‑owned television stations have picked up The Jennifer Hudson Show for a fifth season in 2026‑27, continuing a partnership that’s been in place since the series debuted in fall 2022. 

More Similar Videos

Showboy Shares His Journey From Prison To Becoming Ghana's Biggest Trapper
music,entertainment | Lerny Lomotey | October 27th, 2025

Showboy Shares His Journey From Prison To Becoming Ghana's Biggest Trapper